I was not a huge fan of this cycle. While it did have some very entertaining contestants and moments, it was very lacking. I think maybe it was the photoshoots that dragged it down for me the most. Almost all of them were WAY too gimmicky and completely ridiculous. They were so cheap and tacky looking, and some of the editing done to the pictures seriously looked like it was edited on Microsoft Paint. These photoshoots were even more campy and gimmicky than Cycle 7’s photoshoots were. On top of that, three of the worst photoshoots in the history of the show, (drag queens, four personalities, memorable ANTM moments), happened three consecutive weeks in a row. No agency would ever take a girl seriously, let alone sign her with THAT in her portfolio. They would seriously be laughed right out an agency with photoshoots like the aforementioned three in their portfolios. If I were one of the models, I would be humiliated showing an agency these pictures. Not the best group of girls either. Some of the girls were VERY talented, and unfortunately some of those said talented girls were eliminated WAY too soon. Where as weaker girls made it way further than they should. There were some talented girls that did make it far though, and I was very satisfied with the winner. The final runway was kind of lame too. Like last cycle, it was far too cheesy for me to take seriously. Overall, Cycle 8 was a very dark and somewhat entertaining cycle, and I definitely don’t hate the cycle. But the atrocious photoshoots and not very strong cast kind of drag it down for me a bit.
Like the other seasons, I am going to rank the girls from highest to lowest call out average wise. The overseas group is ranked 1-6, the makeovers group from 7-11, and the rest at 12-13. Now off to the final rankings!
Overseas:
1. Brittany (3.0) 1/6/2/1/6/1/1/5/4
Brittany was no doubt the model of the cycle. I don’t recall her taking even one bad photo. Pre overseas, with the exception of two weeks, she was called within the top two, even securing four first call outs from me! That’s amazing for a fifth placer! There’s no way I’d let her win though, despite ranking #1 in my call out averages. This girl had absolutely no professionalism whatsoever, her meltdown at go sees was a perfect example of that. Despite that though, I don’t think I would’ve eliminated her when she was, even though go sees are part of the show. And even if she did blow it big time with her meltdown. She’d be my runner up.
2. Felicia (3.3) 2/1/3/7
Wow, talk about ranking high for someone who was eliminated fourth! This probably won’t be the only time this will happen, but this is very impressive. Felicia was robbed, BIG time. She spent the first three weeks being called within the Top 3, even earning a first call out the week she took that amazing jock photo. Her elimination is one of the most undeserved in the history of the show. Felicia only took ONE weak photo, that wasn’t even that bad, and gets sent home for it? Yet there were so many other girls who still had to take an impressive photo. Tyra only eliminated her because Felicia resembled her too much. And knowing Tyra, she can’t have anyone resembling her, so off she goes. I would definitely take Felicia overseas in a heartbeat. She’d probably go out Top 6 for me.
3. Natasha (3.8) 7/10/7/2/2/2/2/1/2/4/3
Oh Natasha, such a goofball. Easily the most entertaining contestant this cycle. And she certainly had a strong portfolio too. Natasha managed to get a whopping five second call outs from me, four of those five being consecutive. She even earned a first call out for that Australian CoverGirl commercial. Quite the contrast from the weak start she got off to the first three weeks, which includes her atrocious teachers pet photo. However, Natasha reverted right back to weak pictures the last two weeks of the competition, and took an abysmal CoverGirl picture. Quite possibly the worst CoverGirl picture in the history of the show. Despite ranking high with a greatly improving portfolio, I find Natasha heavily overrated. Cute personality, but I’m just not a huge fan of her. No way would she be runner up like she was on the show. She’d go out fourth place for me, the Aboriginal week.
4. Dionne (4.1) 8/3/6/4/3/4/3/2/5/3
I was never exactly sure how to feel about Dionne. I never loved her, but I never hated her either. She was kind of just there to me, though she did crack me up at times. Her portfolio was pretty good, but not excellent. She never took a stand out shot, despite ranking this high in my call out averages. I was never wowed by her. Plus, she had to be coached in a lot of her photos too, even overseas. Not good for a fourth placer. And I would not have taken her to fourth place either. She’d go out Top 5 for me, the swimsuit week.
5. Jaslene (4.2) 3/2/9/8/1/8/4/4/3/2/2
This may be an unpopular opinion, but Jaslene deserved to win. I realize she was not very consistent, (especially towards the middle of the competition), but she did fit the prizes more than Natasha, so I wasn’t mad at her winning. I’m kind of surprised Jaslene managed to rank only fifth in my averages. I thought for sure she’d rank at least in the Top 3. But I guess some of her lower call outs in the middle of the competition kind of brought her average down a little bit. Still, she managed to earn one first call out from me, for her drag queen shot. While I didn’t give her any of the first call outs she earned on the show, they were still strong pictures that ranked high in my call outs. Despite this rather low ranking of her in my averages, I’d still crown her the winner. And her and Natasha went on to have extremely successful post show careers anyways, so it doesn’t really make a difference at the end of the day.
6. Renee (4.2) 4/12/8/3/5/3/5/3/1/1/1
And here we have, the villain of the cycle. I could not stand Renee. At all. She always picked fights with people just for the sake of picking fights, and she could never be happy for anyone. Even when she did “change” after her intervention with Tyra, I didn’t believe it one bit. Methinks Renee only suppressed her bitchiness because she didn’t want to look too badly on TV. As for her portfolio, it was a pretty good one. She did take some strong pictures, but I wasn’t entirely wowed by her until overseas, where she managed to rack up three consecutive first call outs from me. She definitely earned her spot in the top three, which is where I’d also eliminate her on the show. I do feel bad about what happened to her post show, with her jail time and all. I hope she manages to find herself once she’s released from jail.
Makeovers:
7. Sarah (5.3) 9/7/1/5/4/6
I don’t get the love for this girl. I was only impressed with one picture of hers, (her nude candy picture, which I gave her first call out for), and she was incredibly irritating and bitchy. I don’t understand what people see in her. Unlike the rest of the fandom, I agreed with her elimination. While her final picture wasn’t that bad, it was still way overacted and forced, even for ridiculous photoshoot standards. She goes the same week she did on the show, with the atrocious four personalities photoshoot. I really don’t want to waste anymore time talking about her.
8. Samantha (7.0) 5/9
Another robbed contestant that was eliminated WAY too early. Neither of Samantha’s pictures were bad at all, and she should’ve been given another chance to prove herself. Her second photo was a bit bland, but not elimination worthy at all. Tyra only picked a bad photo on purpose just to justify sending her home. Since as usual, Tyra hates introverts and anyone who does not have a bubbly personality. Despite being eliminated second, Samantha went on to have a major career post show. Take that Tyra! She’d probably go out 7th place for me, for the memorable moments photoshoot week. Samantha’s post show success just goes to show you don’t need to last long or have a major personality to have a successful career.
9. Jael (7.0) 11/4/4/10/9/5/7/6
Hoo boy, another big personality here. Jael seems like a fun person to hang out with…. in small doses. While she seemed like a nice girl, she could be quite irritating at times. And she really did not know when to back off either. Still, I liked Jael, and I still found her entertaining a lot of the time. However, I was not impressed with her portfolio. I only liked maybe two of her pictures, her bookworm and her nude candy picture. Both of which I called fourth, her highest call out position in her averages. The rest of her portfolio ranged from mediocre to absolutely terrible, and I eliminated her a whopping four times. By far the most out of all the girls. That’s not good for someone who makes it overseas. She was basically the Jaeda of the cycle, both ended up in sixth place with weak pictures, and multiple eliminations by me. The only difference is no incessant whining of her hair. She had no business going overseas either. I’d eliminate her drag queen week, for that utterly creepy picture of hers. *shudder* I did however feel bad for her when she fell into her meth addiction after the show. Very shocking and awful. By the looks of things, she seems to have gotten clean and is living a drug free life now. You go Jael!
10. Diana (7.2) 6/5/11/6/8
For a plus size contestant, I was expecting a lot from Diana, talent and personality wise. Sadly, she failed to impress in either category. She took mediocre pictures throughout her stay on the show, even though I did like her first two pictures. And she was super forgettable too. She didn’t seem to get a lot of camera time, and when she did, she appeared stuck up and gossipy. She goes out nude candy week for me, as her picture was absolutely atrocious. Nothing special about this plus size contestant.
11. Whitney (7.4) 10/8/5/9/7/7/6
Another plus size contestant that failed to impress. I’m honestly not sure how she got cast for the show, as her pictures were awful. While she wasn’t nearly as bad as I thought she would be when I ranked her pictures, she had no business making it all the way to the Top 7 on the show. I only liked one picture of hers, her nude candy picture, and even that one wasn’t what I’d call amazing. She’d leave the fourth week for me, the crime scene photoshoot week. I’ve got to say, both plus size models were very disappointing and under performed this cycle. This was not their cycle, that’s for sure.
The Rest:
12. Cassandra (11.0) 12/11/10
Cassandra seemed like such a sweet girl, probably one of the most likable contestants in the history of the show. Unfortunately, this girl could not model to save her life. All three weeks she was on the show she managed to rank in the double digits, and none of her pictures were good. I kind of liked her nude candy picture in a way, but even that photo was lacking. Methinks Tyra only dragged her to makeovers just to get rid of that glued in weave she had. And she certainly looked much better with that afro she received as a makeover. She’d probably go out the second week for me, as she really didn’t have a whole lot of talent at all.
13. Kathleen (13.0) 13
Not a model. While she seemed like a delight to be around and she was entertaining as hell, this girl didn’t have even a lick of potential. Her anti fur picture was absolutely terrible, one of the worst in the cycle, and her elimination was completely deserved. Not much to say about her as she was the first one cut. Oh well, her cluelessness did crack me up, which you don’t see often with a first eliminated girl. If only she had the talent to back it up.