Like my previous write ups, I’m gonna post who should’ve been first call out, bottom two, and eliminated for each of the respective weeks. I will post the actual first call outs, bottom two, and eliminations on the real show, and how I thought those respective call outs/eliminations should’ve gone, and my reasons behind it. After this post, I’m gonna try to get the latest photoshoot from Cycle 24 posted. Also coming after this post will be the intermission, a list of how all the girls I’ve ranked so far on my site. This is a popular list among WordPress sites, and now that I have ranked enough cycles, I will rank the Top 40 girls from highest to lowest averages. And I will NOT be including the Cycle 24 girls on this list, since Cycle 24 is still airing and the girls’ average are naturally, constantly changing. But the highest ranked girls from Cycles 3, 4, 7, and 8 will definitely be on the list. As soon as I’m done posting both of those, then I will rank Cycle 10 next.
Now onto my personal elimination orders!
Week 1:
FCO: Jaslene
Bottom Two: Jael & Kathleen
Eliminated: Kathleen
My FCO: Brittany
My Bottom Two: Jael & Kathleen
My elimination: Kathleen
Reasons: Not much changed outside of Brittany getting first call out over Jaslene the first week. Besides that, the bottom two and elimination remain the same. Kathleen produced an atrocious picture and was absolutely clueless at the photoshoot. So thus, she still goes first.
Week 2:
FCO: Jaslene
Bottom Two: Samantha & Natasha
Eliminated: Samantha
My FCO: Felicia
New Bottom Two: Cassandra & Renee
My elimination: Cassandra
Reasons: There was no doubt Natasha churned out an utterly atrocious picture the second week. But I wouldn’t have necessarily put her in the bottom two for it. And I would NOT have eliminated Samantha just for being an introvert despite having TONS of potential. Who would be the new bottom two then? Renee and Cassandra. The former for taking an abysmal class clown picture, and looking like she has numerous missing limbs. And the latter for taking an utterly uninspiring cheerleader picture, and for taking a weak picture the week before. I will never understand how people could give her cheerleader picture first call out. So Cassandra will be the second one eliminated.
Week 3:
FCO: Brittany
Bottom Two: Cassandra & Diana
Eliminated: Cassandra
My FCO: Sarah
New Bottom Two: Diana & Jaslene
My elimination: Diana
Reasons: With Cassandra gone, the next weakest is Diana, as well as Jaslene’s way too scarily thin body in her picture. Diana and Jaslene are the new bottom two, with Diana getting eliminated next.
Week 4:
FCO: Renee
Bottom Two: Dionne & Felicia
Eliminated: Felicia
My FCO: Brittany
New Bottom Two: Whitney & Jael
My elimination: Whitney
Reasons: NO WAY would Felicia be eliminated, or anywhere near the bottom two this week. Her picture was just a little bland at the worst, it in no way warranted an elimination. And Dionne certainly would not have been in the bottom two either, despite having to be coached at the photoshoot. Thus, the bottom two changes, with Whitney and Jael being in the bottom instead. I feel bad for putting Jael in the bottom two considering this photoshoot came a week after her friend’s death. But lets face it, her picture this week was so blah. She wouldn’t get eliminated though, that honor would go to Whitney, who had by far the weakest portfolio thus far. Funny how my revised bottom two is the same bottom two and eliminated girl as Week 7 on the real show. Possible foreshadowing maybe?
Week 5:
FCO: Natasha
Bottom Two: Whitney & Diana
Eliminated: Diana
My FCO: Jaslene
New Bottom Two: Samantha & Jael
My elimination: Jael
Reasons: With Diana and Whitney gone, the next weakest link after both plus sizes of the cycle is Jael. Her picture was downright cringeworthy, if not nightmare fuel. Plus after coming off of last week with a not so great picture, it would be time to eliminate her here. As for Samantha being in the bottom two with her, I don’t think she’d have the confidence to pull off a cross dressing shot. And I can see her being uncomfortable with posing with drag queens. Thus her joining Jael in the bottom two, but getting spared.
Week 6:
FCO: Jael
Bottom Two: Whitney & Sarah
Eliminated: Sarah
My FCO: Brittany
New Bottom Two: Jaslene & Sarah
My elimination: Sarah
Reasons: Jaslene most definitely should’ve been in the bottom two for her four personalities picture. She had the same look in all four photos! She’d be spared though, and Sarah would still be eliminated, just like she was in the actual episode. She WAY overdid it in all four of her pictures, (even if it was a ridiculous photoshoot), and I don’t get the love for her. So Sarah can go next.
Week 7:
FCO: Dionne
Bottom Two: Whitney & Jael
Eliminated: Whitney
My FCO: Brittany
New Bottom Two: Renee & Samantha
My elimination: Samantha
Reasons: With no Jael or Whitney, the next weakest link would be Renee. While her picture was not terrible, I was not a fan of it either. But I wouldn’t have cut her either, as she still had loads of potential and took VERY strong photos in the weeks after this. My elimination for this week would go to Samantha. For some reason, I just don’t see her pulling off a campy shot like this. So I think 7th place would be a good stopping point for her here.
Week 8:
FCO: Natasha
Bottom Two: Jael & Brittany
Eliminated: Jael
My FCO: Natasha
New Bottom Two: Felicia & Brittany
My elimination: Felicia
Reasons: Brittany sucked hard in her commercial, and no doubt deserved her bottom two appearance this week. But like the real show, I also would’ve kept her around another week. As for the elimination, I think this would’ve been the week I would’ve sent Felicia home. I can’t really picture her pulling off a CoverGirl commercial, in an Australian accent no less. Plus, the other five girls were a bit stronger than her, so 6th place is where Felicia’s journey on the show would end.
Week 9:
FCO: Jaslene
Bottom Two: Dionne & Brittany
Eliminated: Brittany
My FCO: Renee
My Bottom Two: Dionne & Brittany
My elimination: Dionne
Reasons: So the bottom two here is the exact same one on the show. Only Dionne would get cut instead of Brittany. While I do realize Brittany was cut because of her meltdown at go sees, she still had a hell of a lot more to offer at the time of her elimination, and had a far stronger portfolio. Dionne on the other hand, had a far more mediocre portfolio, and STILL needed coaching in her photoshoots. Even this late in the competition. Thus my elimination for Dionne this week instead of Brittany.
Week 10:
FCO: Renee
Bottom Two: Dionne & Natasha
Eliminated: Dionne
My FCO: Renee
New Bottom Two: Jaslene & Natasha
My elimination: Natasha
Reasons: Funny how my revised bottom two is the final two on the actual show. Natasha’s picture this week was absolutely abysmal, and really should’ve been eliminated that week. And with Dionne already gone, she honestly would have been eliminated. As for Jaslene, I don’t actually consider her picture bottom two worthy. But with Renee and Brittany still in the competition, it would just push her down to that bottom position. And honestly, I don’t think Brittany would screw up a photoshoot like that of the Aboriginal. Jaslene would still be spared though, and Natasha would get the boot at fourth place.
Week 11:
FCO: Jaslene
Bottom Two: Natasha & Renee
Eliminated: Renee
My FCO: Jaslene
New Bottom Two: Brittany & Renee
My elimination: Renee
Reasons: Despite taking the only halfway decent CoverGirl picture this cycle, I’d still choose to eliminate Renee because I happened to prefer both Jaslene and Brittany more. The next strongest picture after Renee was Jaslene, who I would give first call out to. Besides that, only the bottom two has changed from my revised version to the actual show. Only difference is Brittany is in the final two with Jaslene instead of Natasha.
Final Two: Jaslene & Brittany
America’s Next Top Model is…. Jaslene!
So Jaslene wins here, just like she did on the actual show. I know she wasn’t always consistent, but she was a very strong competitor and I was glad that she won. Brittany would be my runner up, as her portfolio was nearly flawless. She could never cut it as a winner though, as she was highly unprofessional at times. Thus why Jaslene wins, and Brittany is the runner up for me.
Final Standings (Bottom twos):
1. Jaslene – (Winner) (3)
2. Brittany – (Runner Up) (3)
3. Renee (3)
4. Natasha (1)
5. Dionne (1)
6. Felicia (1)
7. Samantha (2)
8. Sarah (1)
9. Jael (3)
10. Whitney (1)
11. Diana (1)
12. Cassandra (1)
13. Kathleen (1)